A Progress of Sentiments: Reflections on Hume's Treatise by Annette C. Baier

By Annette C. Baier

Annette Baier's goal is to make experience of David Hume's Treatise as a complete. Hume's family members motto, which seems on his bookplate, was once "True to the End." Baier argues that it's not until eventually the top of the Treatise that we get his complete tale approximately "truth and falsehood, cause and folly." through the top, we will be able to see the reason to which Hume has been precise through the paintings.

Baier unearths Hume's Treatise of Human Nature to be a gently crafted literary and philosophical paintings which itself screens a philosophical development of sentiments. His beginning is an excessively summary intellectualism that intentionally thrusts passions and social issues into the history. within the 3 interrelated books of the Treatise , his "self-understander" proceeds via partial successes and dramatic disasters to emerge with new-found optimism, waiting for that the "exact wisdom" the morally self-conscious anatomist of human nature can collect will itself enhance and proper our imaginative and prescient of morality. Baier describes how, via turning philosophy towards human nature rather than towards God and the universe, Hume initiated a brand new philosophy, a broader self-discipline of mirrored image that could embody Charles Darwin and Michel Foucault in addition to William James and Sigmund Freud. Hume belongs either to our current and to our earlier.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Progress of Sentiments: Reflections on Hume's Treatise PDF

Similar other social sciences books

A Progress of Sentiments: Reflections on Hume's Treatise

Annette Baier's goal is to make feel of David Hume's Treatise as an entire. Hume's relations motto, which looks on his bookplate, was once "True to the top. " Baier argues that it's not until eventually the tip of the Treatise that we get his complete tale approximately "truth and falsehood, cause and folly. " by way of the tip, we will be able to see the reason to which Hume has been actual in the course of the paintings.

Extra info for A Progress of Sentiments: Reflections on Hume's Treatise

Sample text

The new philosophy will be a "science" (a deliberate attempt to get knowledge) of human nature. " This "science," Hume had told us in the "Introduction" to the Treatise, will not be able to experiment, in our contemporary sense of the term, upon the thing it studies, as Newton could experiment on bodies. "When I am at a loss to know the effects of one body upon another in any situation, I need only put them in that situation, and observe what results from it. But should I endeavour to clear up after the same manner any doubt in moral philosophy, by placing myself in the same case with that which I consider, 'tis evident this reflection and premeditation would so disturb the operation of my natural principles, as must render it impossible to form any just conclusion from the phaenomenon" (T.

Ridiculous indeed. We have now arrived at a mental state stable enough to serve to launch Books Two and Three. The thoughtless sociability of the backgammon table has been followed by a return to the study. " All that remains to be done, before beginning the new reformed philosophy, is to announce its program and method as clearly as possible. In doing that, in the final pages of the conclusion, Hume recognizes that those outside the study, the "many honest gentlemen" who will never read the Treatise) have a crucial role to play in the grounding of any inventions or discoveries that the new philosophy may advance.

Hume does not give us this reversal, in his claims about simples and complexes. "Her smile" is for him officially a very complex idea, a "mode," while the simpler ideas will be of her face color, her mouth size, shape and so on. "We cannot form to ourselves a just idea of the taste of a pine-apple, without having actually tasted it" (T. 5 And no more can we form a just idea of a welcoming smile or of rejoicing company without having savored that. Although in theory Hume's empiricism requires him to distinguish simple from complex perceptions, since it is only simple ideas that must be traced back to simple impressions (T.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.71 of 5 – based on 38 votes